4 Comments
User's avatar
Edward Anselm's avatar

I read the interview and the full report with great interest. I fully support the conclusions of the paper, but I believe insufficient analysis of cessation diminishes the credibility of the arguments. My experience is limited to the US experience and is summarized in several Substack articles.

https://edwardanselm.substack.com/p/the-missing-link-in-tobacco-treatment?r=fp3rx

https://edwardanselm.substack.com/p/better-treatment-for-people-who-use?r=fp3rx

role of alternative nicotine products in tobacco harm reduction.

https://edwardanselm.substack.com/p/learned-helplessness-in-tobacco-treatment?r=fp3rx

The core arguments of the report would only be enhanced by explaining why tobacco treatment does not appear to be as effective as other medical treatments.

Derek Yach's avatar

A real privilege to share my views and insights about ending smoking with you. Look forward to comments and feedback.

Prof. Jean-Francois Etter's avatar

Thanks again, I really appreciate your answers.

Derek Yach's avatar

Thanks and agree that more on cessation would be helpful- but great you filled that gap!